Rev. Mark H. Creech
When history cools the anger: Will Trump be judged differently someday?
FacebookTwitter
By Rev. Mark H. Creech
October 1, 2026

History sometimes views a president differently than the people who lived through his presidency.

Abraham Lincoln certainly knew what it meant to be despised. During the 1864 campaign, he was called a despot, liar, buffoon, usurper, fiend, butcher, and worse. As the Civil War dragged on and casualties mounted, Lincoln himself believed, for a time, that he might lose reelection. Today, Americans remember him primarily for preserving the Union and issuing the Emancipation Proclamation. He is now possibly the most memorable and beloved president in American history.

Harry Truman faced something similar. By February 1952, his Gallup approval rating had fallen to 22 percent. The Korean War dragged on, labor unrest and inflation troubled the nation, and corruption accusations battered his administration. Yet history later gave greater weight to the Marshall Plan, the Berlin Airlift, NATO, resistance to Soviet expansion, recognition of Israel, and the desegregation of the armed forces. Today, Truman is generally regarded far more favorably than he was when he left office and is frequently ranked by historians among the stronger American presidents.

None of this suggests Donald Trump is another Lincoln or Truman. But their stories remind us of something important: The passions of the present do not always produce the clearest judgment of a presidency.

What might Americans someday say about Trump when the anger surrounding him has cooled? Set aside his personality, rhetoric, and controversies for a moment and ask a simpler question: What has his administration actually done?

Border Security and Public Safety

At the southern border, the change has been dramatic. In May 2025, Border Patrol recorded 8,725 illegal crossings between ports of entry along the southwest border, a 93 percent decrease from May 2024. Border Patrol also reported releasing no illegal migrants into the country that month, compared with more than 62,000 the previous May.

Violent crime also fell sharply in 2025. FBI data show the violent-crime rate dropped 9.3 percent, with murder down 18.1 percent and robbery down 18.5 percent. Crime trends have many causes, but these developments are real and deserve acknowledgment.

The American Family and Household Economy

The Census Bureau reported that inflation-adjusted median household income reached a record $87,460 in 2025, while the official poverty rate fell to 10.2 percent—the lowest level in the past decade and below the decade’s average of roughly 11.4 percent. The official child-poverty rate also fell to a historic low of 13.4 percent. Trump also signed major tax legislation that increased the standard deduction and created or expanded deductions for tips, overtime, seniors, and qualifying car-loan interest. Not every family qualifies for every provision, but these are tangible changes affecting ordinary Americans.

Energy, National Security, and Veterans

U.S. crude-oil production reached another record in 2025, averaging about 13.6 million barrels per day. Trump also pressed NATO allies to assume greater responsibility for their own defense, culminating in a new commitment to significantly higher defense spending.

Trump has taken direct military action against Iran, a country the United States has long designated a state sponsor of terrorism and that has supported groups such as Hezbollah, Hamas, the Houthis, and Iranian-backed militias in Iraq and Syria. His administration has argued that confronting Iran itself – not merely its proxies – is necessary to weaken those networks and to prevent Tehran from acquiring a nuclear weapon.

Through Operation Epic Fury, Trump ordered military action to destroy Iran’s missile capabilities, cripple its navy, disrupt its support for terrorist proxies, and deny it a path to nuclear weapons. His administration has followed those operations with continued economic pressure on Iran and on organizations tied to its regional network.

The wisdom, costs, and long-term consequences of that war will undoubtedly be debated. But Trump has taken a far more direct approach to the Iranian regime than many previous administrations, confronting what successive U.S. governments have identified as a major source of terrorism and instability in the Middle East.

Veterans have also seen measurable improvements, with the VA reporting by July 2026 that its backlog of disability and pension claims had fallen by more than 74 percent since January 2025.

For Christians, There Is Another Part of the Record

For evangelical Christians, Catholics, and other religious conservatives, Trump’s record encompasses issues of even great moral significance.

Life and the Unborn

Perhaps no presidential decision has had greater consequences for the pro-life movement than Trump’s three Supreme Court appointments: Neil Gorsuch, Brett Kavanaugh, and Amy Coney Barrett. All three later joined the majority in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, the 2022 ruling that overturned Roe v. Wade. For generations of pro-life Christians who had prayed, marched, organized, and voted for that day, it was no small accomplishment.

Since returning to the White House, Trump has directed stricter enforcement of the Hyde Amendment and related restrictions on taxpayer funding of elective abortion. His administration ordered federal agencies to review their policies, audit programs where prohibited abortion funding might have occurred, and report on their compliance. He also reinstated the Mexico City Policy, which restricts U.S. foreign assistance to organizations that perform or promote abortion abroad. His administration also ended federal reimbursement for certain abortion-related travel expenses and other policies it viewed as circumventing longstanding funding restrictions.

Religious Liberty and Conscience

Trump established the White House Faith Office, created a Religious Liberty Commission, and launched a Justice Department task force to investigate anti-Christian bias. His administration has also strengthened conscience protections and emphasized the religious rights of pastors, churches, students, teachers, chaplains, parents, and faith-based institutions.

Parents, Children, and Biological Sex

Trump has promoted parental rights and school choice, including access to religious education. His administration has also opposed federal support for gender-transition procedures for minors and restored a federal definition of sex based on the biological distinction between male and female. He further directed federal agencies to protect women’s athletics from male participation under Title IX.

For many Christians, these are not merely political questions. They concern human nature, parental authority, and the protection of children.

Israel and Faith in the Public Square

Trump has maintained a strongly supportive posture toward Israel and has directed additional federal action against antisemitism, particularly on college campuses. His administration has also adopted a much more welcoming posture toward public religious expression, repeatedly affirming that churches, pastors, religious schools, and believers have a legitimate place in American civic life.

For Christians who have watched traditional beliefs grow increasingly marginalized, that matters.

Why I Am Willing to Voice My Support

Someone may read all of this and still dislike Donald Trump. That is their prerogative. But disliking a man and refusing to acknowledge anything good he has done are two different things.

We see that distinction play out almost daily in real time. A border can become more secure, crime can fall, veterans can receive faster service, strong national-security measures can be taken against Iran’s nuclear ambitions and terrorist networks, religious-liberty protections can be strengthened, Roe v. Wade can be overturned, and policies protecting parental rights, unborn life, and women’s sports can be advanced. Yet for some, the first instinct is not to acknowledge the accomplishment but to minimize it, explain it away, or immediately change the subject to Trump’s personality and other controversies.

That does not mean every favorable development should be credited entirely to him, nor does it make criticism of him illegitimate. But when a man’s critics can't admit even the obvious good, something more than ordinary political disagreement is at play. At that point, dislike begins to distort judgment.

That distinction matters especially to me because of something I learned years ago while in the pastorate.

I served six churches over twenty years. One of those pastorates became extraordinarily painful. A powerful faction had controlled the church for decades and resisted anything that threatened that control. My Christ-centered, evangelistic preaching did not sit well with them either.

The criticism became relentless, and most of it was unfair.

But the critics didn't wound me most.

The silence of good people did.

There were members who knew the truth and knew that what was being said about me was wrong, yet many remained quiet and left me largely to defend myself. I have never forgotten that.

It taught me this: when a man is relentlessly attacked and you know there is another side to the story, silence is not always neutral. Sometimes silence merely leaves the field to the accusers. And that isn’t right!

That is one reason I am willing to write an article like this. I may lose some of the people who follow my work because of it. Nevertheless, I believe the constant barrage of criticism this president has faced has often gone far beyond fair political disagreement. Too much of it has become personal, relentless, and unwilling to acknowledge anything good.

News flash! Donald Trump has feet of clay.

So do I.

So did Lincoln.

So did Truman.

Trump has said and done things that some may legitimately criticize.

Supporting a president should never require pretending otherwise. But fairness also requires giving a man his due.

I am proud to say that I support my President. I believe his administration has done considerable good for this country, especially in matters of profound importance to Christians.

History will render its own judgment. But I would not be surprised if, when today’s political passions have finally cooled, future generations look back and wonder why so many Americans seemed unable to acknowledge achievements that were plainly evident.

Lincoln’s critics had their day. Truman’s had theirs.

History kept writing after the shouting stopped. It will do the same with Donald Trump.

As for me, I do not want to look back someday and realize that when I believed fairness required a voice, I chose silence instead.

______________________________

Read this article and many others by Dr. Creech at RevMarkCreech.org.

Share Truth for Our Times

If this article helped you in some way, please consider forwarding it to a friend, pastor, or family member.

Speaking Engagements

Churches, ministries, and civic organizations are invited to prayerfully consider Dr. Mark Creech as a speaker for worship services, revival meetings, conferences, and special events. Dr. Creech speaks on biblical faith, cultural engagement, public policy, and the Christian worldview, delivering messages that are faithful to Scripture and deeply relevant to the challenges of our time.

For scheduling inquiries:

RevMarkCreech.org/booking

919-915-3033

mark@revmarkcreech.org

© Rev. Mark H. Creech

 

The views expressed by RenewAmerica columnists are their own and do not necessarily reflect the position of RenewAmerica or its affiliates.
(See RenewAmerica's publishing standards.)

Click to enlarge

Rev. Mark H. Creech

Rev. Mark H. Creech served as Executive Director of the Christian Action League of North Carolina for twenty-five years. Before leading that ministry, he spent two decades in pastoral service, shepherding five Southern Baptist churches across North Carolina and one Independent Baptist congregation in upstate New York. He now serves as Director of Government Relations for Return America.

A seasoned voice for Christian values in the public square and a registered lobbyist in the North Carolina General Assembly, Rev. Creech is also a respected speaker and writer. His editorials have appeared not only on RenewAmerica.com, The Christian Post, and other online platforms, but also in most major daily newspapers throughout North Carolina.

Whether in the pulpit, the halls of government, or the media, his mission has remained steadfast – to call the Church and the nation to redemption and righteousness.

Subscribe

Receive future articles by Rev. Mark H. Creech: Click here

More by this author

 

Stephen Stone
A message to all who love our country and want to help save it

Stephen Stone
The most egregious lies Evan McMullin and the media have told about Sen. Mike Lee

Siena Hoefling
Protect the Children: Update with VIDEO

Stephen Stone
FLASHBACK to 2020: Dems' fake claim that Trump and Utah congressional hopeful Burgess Owens want 'renewed nuclear testing' blows up when examined

Peter Lemiska
Socialism: Born of ignorance and envy

Jerry Newcombe
Last chance to register to vote

Rev. Mark H. Creech
Did you know voters will decide on three changes to NC’s constitution this election?

Tom DeWeese
Down the rabbit holes of regionalism

Curtis Dahlgren
RECOLLECTIONS: FYI from 2009

Rev. Mark H. Creech
What J.D. Greear gets right, and what his Christian Nationalism argument misses

Mark Malaszczyk
The idiot’s guide to excusing terrorism

Tom DeWeese
It’s getting late! It’s now or never

Mark Malaszczyk
The generation of whiners: Why today’s delayed-adulting snowflakes are an insult to the graves of actual survivors

Rev. Mark H. Creech
When Christian teaching turned on the Jews

Selwyn Duke
Indonesia’s government is trying to censor my “Great Replacement” speech

Cherie Zaslawsky
Lindsay Clancy’s Devil’s Bargain
  More columns

Cartoons


Click for full cartoon
More cartoons

Columnists

Matt C. Abbott
Chris Adamo
Russ J. Alan
Bonnie Alba
Chuck Baldwin
Kevin J. Banet
J. Matt Barber
Fr. Tom Bartolomeo
. . .
[See more]

Sister sites